Case by Case
When done, this section will provide the following basic information on every Law & Order case:
episode (and episode number), the prosecuting team, the judge, the defense attorney(s), the defendant(s), the indictment and the verdict.
We can get this done a lot faster with help from other L&O fans.
If you would like to provide us with the basics of a case, we'll give you the credit!
Just use the handy form at the bottom of the page, or send submissions to lawandorder3x@lycos.com.
WARNING: This page contains "spoilers"
Episode
|
Prosecutors
|
Judge
|
Defense
|
Defendant
|
Indictment
|
Verdict
|
|
"Angel"
# 119
|
McCoy /
Kincaid
|
Rebecca Stein
|
Ross Fineman
|
Leah Coleman
|
Murder 2
|
Guilty
[contributed anonymously]
|
|
"Armed Forces"
# 255
|
McCoy/
Southerlyn
|
|
Ms. Gardner
|
Nolan Tinsdale & Stanley Fletcher
|
Murder 2
|
Both defendants pled guilty to Manslaughter 2
[contributed by
David Stanaland]
|
|
"Asterick"
# 285
|
McCoy / Southerlyn
|
Walter Bradley
|
Alan Fenwick
|
Kevin Seleeby
|
Murder 1
|
Guilty
|
|
"Asylum"
# 26
|
Stone /
Robinette
|
Bernard O'Malley
|
Mr. Scoler
|
James Polesky
|
Murder 2
|
Guilty verdict overturned; pled to Manslaughter 1
|
|
"Attorney Client"
# 275
|
McCoy /
Southerlyn
|
|
Charlotte Swan
|
Harold Jensen
|
Murder 2
|
Guilty
|
|
"Bad Faith"
# 108
|
McCoy /
Kincaid
|
Novack
|
Judy Marino
|
Father Joe Krolinsky
|
Agg. Sex Abuse 1
(19 counts)
|
Pled to Sexual Abuse
(19 counts)
(15 years)
|
|
"Blood"
# 164
|
McCoy /
Ross
|
Rebecca Stein
|
Ms. Joyner
|
Frances Houston
|
Murder 2
|
Pled to Manslaughter 1 (8.33-25 yrs.)
|
|
"Burden"
# 177
|
McCoy / Ross
|
Henry Fillmore
|
Gillum
|
Lyle Semenko
|
Murder 2, Man 1,
Man 2
|
Not guilty Murder 2/Man 1
Guilty Man 2
[contributed anonymously]
|
|
"Coma"
# 90
|
McCoy/
Kincaid
|
Elizabeth Yee
|
?
|
Michael Dobson
|
Murder 2
|
Dismissed
[contributed anonymously]
|
|
"Corpus Delicti"
# 122
|
McCoy /
Kincaid
|
Henry Fillmore
|
James Linde
|
Lyle Christopher
|
Murder 2
|
Mistrial
|
|
"Empire"
# 201
|
McCoy /
Carmichael
|
Richard Tabachini
|
Mosbeck
|
Julian Spector
|
Murder 2
|
Guilty
|
|
"Encore"
# 126
|
McCoy/
Kincaid
|
Harold Kaiser
|
|
Michael Dobson
|
Murder 1
|
Guilty
(death penalty)
|
|
"Endurance"
# 230
|
McCoy /
Carmichael
|
Elaine Schepps
|
Barry Peck
|
Megan Parnell
|
Murder 2
|
|
|
"Equal Rights"
# 271
|
McCoy /
Southerlyn
|
Arlene Brewer
|
|
Leslie Cooper
|
Murder 1
|
Not guilty
|
|
"Expert"
# 169
|
McCoy /
Ross
|
Herman Mooney
|
Jane Powell
|
Lindsay Carson
|
Murder 1
|
Pled to Murder 1
(25 yrs. to life)
|
|
"Family Business"
# 142
|
McCoy / Ross
|
Grace Larkin
|
|
Laura Bergreen
|
Murder 2
|
Not guilty
[contributed anonymously]
|
|
"Girlfriends"
# 131
|
McCoy /
Kincaid
|
Margaret Barry
|
Ms. Shore
|
Shelly Taggart
|
Murder 2
|
Not guilty
|
|
# 99
"Guardian"
|
McCoy / Kincaid
|
Luis Rodriguez
|
Dean Pollard
|
Jerome Kamen
|
Murder 2
|
Pled to Manslaughter 1
(8.33-25 yrs)
|
|
"Gunshow"
# 206
|
McCoy /
Carmichael
|
Joseph Flint
|
Charles Powell
|
Dennis Trope
|
Murder 2, 15 counts
|
Pled to one count, Murder 2 (25 yrs - life)
|
|
"
"
|
McCoy /
Carmichael
|
William Wright
|
Charlotte Swan
|
Weber (Rolfe)
|
Murder 2, 15 counts
|
Guilty; set aside by judge, finding: not guilty
|
|
"Haven"
# 193
|
McCoy /
Carmichael
|
David Wilcox
|
Charles Perry
|
Jerome Warren
|
Murder 2
|
Pled to Manslaughter 1 (6-12 yrs)
|
|
"Hot Pursuit"
# 116
|
McCoy /
Kincaid
|
Herman Mooney
|
Danielle Melnick
|
Leslie Harlan
|
Murder 2
(4 counts)
|
Guilty on all counts
|
|
"A Losing Season"
# 243
|
McCoy /
Carmichael
|
?
|
?
|
Christopher Coty
|
Murder 1
|
Guilty
[contributed by Eugene Kim]
|
|
"Matrimony"
# 147
|
McCoy /
Ross
|
Robert Quinn
|
Arthur Gold
|
Kim Triandos
|
Murder 2
|
Not guilty; her mother, Velma Darcy, committed the crime
|
|
"Nurture"
# 86
|
Stone /
Kincaid
|
Randall Welch
|
Rose Seigel
|
Arnette Fenady
|
Kidnapping 2
|
Not guilty
|
|
"Open Season"
# 284
|
McCoy / Southerlyn
|
|
Danielle Melnick
|
Julian Preuss
|
Murder 2, Robbery 1
|
Pled to Conspiracy 1, Manslaughter 1
[contributed anonymously]
|
|
"Past Imperfect"
# 156
|
McCoy /
Ross
|
Elizabeth Yee
|
Marjorie Larson
|
Sonja Harlann
|
Murder 2
|
Pled to Manslaughter 1 (12.5-25 yrs.)
|
|
"Patriot"
# 271
|
McCoy / Southerlyn
|
Lisa Pondracic
|
Lester Hastings
|
Frank Miller
|
Murder 2
|
Guilty
|
|
"Patsy"
# 212
|
McCoy /
Carmichael
|
Ida Boucher
|
Charles Garnett
|
Ken Taylor
|
Murder 2
|
Mistrial
|
|
"Phobia"
# 242
|
McCoy /
Carmichael
|
not named
|
Shambala Green
|
Robert Kelly
|
Manslaught-
er 1 w/ bias
|
Guilty
|
|
"Poison Ivy"
# 8
|
Stone /
Robinette
|
Harvey Sirkin
|
Mr. Hillary
|
Fredo Parisi
|
Murder 2
|
Defendant commits suicide prior to verdict
|
|
"Prejudice"
# 263
|
McCoy /
Southerlyn
|
Rebecca Stein
|
Al Archer
|
Ray Burrows
|
Murder 2
|
Guilty
[contributed anonymously]
|
|
"Punk"
# 189
|
McCoy /
Carmichael
|
Allan Denham
|
Danielle Melnick
|
Alice Simonelli
|
Murder 1
|
Pled to attempted Manslaughter 1 (3-6 yrs)
|
|
"Refuge II"
# 205
|
McCoy/
Carmichael
|
Hewlett
|
?
|
Carlton Radford
|
Enterprise
Corruption
|
Guilty
[contributed by
David Stanaland]
|
|
"Savages"
# 114
|
McCoy /
Kincaid
|
Ida Boucher
|
Helen Brolin
|
Paul Sandig
|
Murder 1
|
Guilty
(rec'd the death sentence)
|
|
"Scoundrels"'
# 97
|
McCoy /
Kincaid
|
Pamela Jensen
|
Sally Bell
|
John Curren
|
Murder 2
|
Pled to Manslaughter 1 (8.33-25 yrs)
|
|
"
"
|
McCoy /
Kincaid
|
Herman Mooney
|
Edward St. John
|
Willard Tappan
|
Murder 2
|
Guilty
|
|
"Severance"
# 35
|
Stone /
Robinette
|
Jenklaw
|
Arthur Gold/
David Werner/
Sharon Styger
|
Larry Teasdale / Frank Kemp / Charles Martine
|
Murder 2
(3 counts)
|
Teasdale and Kemp pled to Manslaughter 1; Martine was found guilty, Murder 2 (3 counts)
|
|
"Shangri-La"
# 279
|
McCoy /
Southerlyn
|
Shirley Taylor
|
Jessica Sheets
|
Fiona Reed
|
Murder 2
|
Pled to Manslaughter 1 (8.33-25 years)
|
|
"Showtime"
# 151
|
McCoy /
Ross
|
Michael Callahan
|
Neal Gorton
Ms. Joyner
|
Eddie Newman
|
Murder 1
|
Guilty
(rec'd the death sentence)
|
|
"Sisters of Mercy"
# 39
|
Stone / Robinette
|
Irwin Reisman
|
McCarter
|
Jack Powell
|
Rape 1
|
Guilty
[contributed anonymously]
|
|
"Teenage Wasteland"
# 241
|
McCoy / Carmichael
|
Walter Schreiber
|
Leslie Stanton
|
Mitch Regan
|
Murder 1
|
Guilty
(rec'd the death sentence)
|
|
"Trophy"
# 123
|
McCoy /
Kincaid
|
Walter Schreiber
|
Gerald Fox
|
Diana
Hawthorne
|
Criminal Facilitation 2
|
Pled to Criminal Facilitation 4 and lost her license to practice law
|
|
"Turnstile Justice"
# 231
|
McCoy / Carmichael
|
Elizabeth Mizener
|
|
Philip Andrews
|
Man 2, Crim. Neg. Homicide
|
Not guilty, Man 2;
Guilty, Crim. Neg. Hom.
[contributed anonymously]
|
|
"Under the Influence"
# 168
|
McCoy /
Ross
|
Gary Feldman
|
Richard Billings
|
Bernard Dressler
|
Murder 1
|
Pled to 3 counts of Vehicular Manslaughter (5-15 years)
|
|
"Under-covered"
# 265
|
McCoy/
Southerlyn
|
Harrison Taylor
|
Nick Margolis
|
Tony Garcia
|
Kidnapping
&
Murder 1
|
Mistrial
[contributed by
David Stanaland]
|
|
"Vaya con Dios"
# 229
|
McCoy /
Carmichael
|
Busey
|
Leon Chiles
|
Col. Emilio Pantoya
|
Conspiracy (to Commit Murder) 1
|
Guilty
|
|
"Venom"
# 188
|
McCoy /
Carmichael
|
Margaret
Barry
|
Daniel
Metzler
|
Dennis Pollock
|
Murder 2
|
Not guilty; guilty, Man-slaughter 1 (8.33-25 yrs.)
|
|
"We Like Mike"
# 154
|
McCoy / Ross
|
Aldo Iannello
|
Mr. Shuman
|
Ricky Garcia
|
Murder 1, Robbery 1
|
Guilty on both counts
[contributed anonymously]
|
|
"Whiplash"
# 248
|
McCoy /
Carmichael
|
Shirley Taylor
|
Doug Lyle
|
A. Petrie &
P. Saunders
|
Murder 2
|
Guilty
|
|
"Who Let the Dogs Out?"
# 254
|
McCoy / Southerlyn
|
Albert Scholl
|
Peter Behrens
|
Shem & Roger Quinn
|
Man 2 (one count each)
|
Both pled to Manslaughter 2 (2-6 yrs.)
[contributed anonymously]
|
|
My apologies to any who have tried to use the form below in the past couple of months. I believe it's fully operational now.
However, if you have any doubts, or problems with it, please email your Case-by-Case submission to
lawandorder3x@lycos.com
I deeply appreciate your help in expanding this feature!